Holika Holika Wonder Drawing Dot Eyeliner Review

July 11, 2013

Let’s continue with my reviews for Korean Makeup. The product I am reviewing today Holika Holika Wonder Drawing Dot Liner is probably one of the cheapest products that has ever been featured on this blog, but hey I cannot believe I lived so many years without it! Basically it’s a liquid eyeliner that is designed for filling the white gaps between your lashes, and it is the drugstore version of the Clarins 3 dot eyeliner which was limited edition.


If you are fussy with your eyeliner, you would know it takes more than just drawing a straight line along the lashes. To make it appear more perfect, there are 3 steps involved:  1.draw the waterline (the inner rim), 2. draw the regular line as close to the lashes as possible. 3. fill any white gaps between the lashes.

I never like to follow the makeup rules, and to me I like to find my own ways to enhance my features as everyone is different. Unlike most people, I cannot see the upper inner rim when my eyes are opened, therefore I never draw the upper waterline because it doesn’t make any difference to my eyes. Another feature I have noticed on myself is that my upper lid slightly overlaps with the lower lid when my eyes are closed (compared to the upper lid sitting right on top of the lower lid for most people), so whichever eyeliner I use to rim the waterline it will always smudge terribly.

Here is where this magical product comes in! If you look at your eyes closely, you will always see some white spots between the lashes after the eyeliner and mascara are applied. I normally just use a regular liquid eyeliner to fill these gaps one by one, and it’s very time consuming. With this product, it takes no time to do this and it just works perfectly. It’s a very trivial step that is easily neglected, but by filling in these gaps, they make a huge difference to my eyes in terms of depth. In addition, if you are skilled enough, this is also an ideal product for drawing fake lower lashes. The only gripe about this product is that it’s impossible to be removed. It’s great as it has never smudged on me, but be prepared to spend more time for removal.

Bottom Line: A must have eyeliner product if you are a perfectionist with your eye makeup! Holika Holika wonder drawing dot eyeliner can be purchased here with more information and pictures on how to use this product.

{ 10 comments… read them below or add one }

cilucia July 11, 2013 at 4:50 pm

I’m a big fan of this product! I also tried the KATE version, but it was a lot scratchier than the Holika Holika one.

I buy mine on ebay for about $9 USD shipped.


Reika July 13, 2013 at 4:05 pm

Oh..I also bought the kate one recently as I wanted to compare it with HH 🙂


Ami S. July 11, 2013 at 5:42 pm

I appreciate all your reviews! You’re so thorough. Your blog is wonderful in general. 🙂 I purchased this product years ago when I heard Jen frmheadtotoe rave about it, but unfortunately I didn’t get along with it at all. I found the prongs difficult to work with and the real deal-breaker for me was the formula of the ink. It was so watery and thin, and it faded from black to blue! It literally stained my eyelids blue… perhaps I got a defective one?


Reika July 13, 2013 at 4:04 pm

Thank you Ami! I don’t have any problem with my HH pen – the ink is slightly watery (but it doesn’t bother me) but it never fades on me….maybe they have improved the formula after so many years..?


Julie Fischer July 12, 2013 at 9:20 am

I bought Holika Holika Wonder Drawing Dot Liner after a lackluster experience with Too Faced’s ‘3-Way Lash Lining Tool’ (raccoon eyes in 2-3 hours). I was at first skeptical of the whole 3-prong eyeliner concept, convinced that it was a gimmicky trend – but I use it nearly everyday now, and I am so pleased by HH’s graphic, yet natural results. I agree that its removal is a chore, however. I always resort to a double cleansing with the HH eyeliner. Thank you for the review, Reika!


Reika July 13, 2013 at 4:02 pm

I completely agree with you Julie. I didn’t think it would be a product that I would reach for everyday when I first bought it! And it’s my HG now 🙂


Justine July 12, 2013 at 12:29 pm

I use the same one but a different brand (Nature Republic) which is so great. I might try Holika Holika one of these days.


Reika July 13, 2013 at 4:00 pm

Thanks for letting me know Justine! I’ll try out nature republic next time!


angie July 13, 2013 at 1:14 am

hi. love your blog. could you do an updated list of your HG product in each category please? thanks much.

ange xx


Reika July 13, 2013 at 4:00 pm

Hi Angie, I am in the process of putting together some of my favorites products for each category 🙂


Leave a Comment

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Previous post:

Next post: