Best Liquid Eyeliners

by Reika on July 12, 2011

Nothing defines my eyes better than the use of an intense black eyeliner – it is something I cannot live without since high school! I am always on the hunt for the best, blackest and smoothest black liquid eyeliner. I have tried tons of them from the most expensive brands to the most affordable. This post is going to be a comparison of some of the best liquid eyeliners that I have tried so far, and the good news is..most of them are drugstore brands and cost less $12 bucks!

All of these eyeliners are intensely black. They all have a  fine tip which allows for easy application and gives a precise and clean line. They go on smoothly and fluidly without smudging and last all day.

From Left to Right:

1. Dolly Wink Liquid Eyeliner in Deep Black: felt tip

2. Majolica Perfect Automatic Liner in BK999: brush tip

3. Koji Linequeen in Strong Black:  brush tip

4. MAC Superslick Liquid Eye Liner in On The Hunt: felt tip

5. K-Palette Real Lasting Eyeliner 24h in 01 (best seller in one of the biggest Japanese drugstores): has a brush tip and claims that it wears like a tattoo for 24 hrs

best-black-liquid-eyeliners-dolly-wink-majolica-koji-mac

Battle 1:  THE FINEST TIP

Winner:  Koji Linequeen has the most ultra fine tip of only 0.1mm – perfect for defining the winged look precisely. (shown in the far right)

Runner Up: K-Palette Real Lasting Eyeliner 24h (shown 2nd from the right)

best-black-liquid-eyeliners-dolly-wink-majolica-koji-mac-1

Battle 2: THE BLACKEST BLACK – tested with swatching each eyeliner with only 1 stroke at the same pressure

Winner: Dolly Wink Liquid Eyeliner in Deep Black

Runner Ups: MAC ties with Majolica

best-black-liquid-eyeliners-dolly-wink-majolica-koji-mac-2

Battle 3: MOST SMUDGE PROOF – tested with rubbing my fingers over them several times

Winner: Majolica Perfect Automatic Liner - the opacity stays the same while the rest show signs of fading.

Worst Performance: MAC – the only one that starts to flake off.

Battle 4: MOST WATERPROOF – tested with spraying water over them

Winners: All good except for K-Palette

Worst Performance: K-Palette starts to come off as soon as it touches the water

Battle 5: BEST STAYING POWER – swiping them off using a cotton pad

Winner: Dolly Wink

Runner Up: K-Palette – although the color has faded you can still see the remnant (“the tattoo effect”)  in a smooth line

Battle 6: EASIEST TO REMOVE -removed them using Bioderma Sensibio H2O Crealine Cleanser

Winners: All good except for K-Palette

Worst Performance: K-Palette: it definitely wears like a tattoo

Prices:

MAC: >$30 in Australia (cannot remember the exact price)

The rest of the brands: <$15

I know we are all looking for different qualities from an eyeliner. I hope this post would help if you are interested in any of these brands. After years of experimenting I really think there is no point of spending more than $15 on a liquid eyeliner. The drugstore brands, especially the Japanese ones are just as good. As for me, hands down, I would repurchase Dolly Wink and Majolica over and over. They are the best!

 

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

{ 24 comments… read them below or add one }

flyavsted July 12, 2011 at 12:22 pm

Great review! I think our next holiday must go to Japan!;) I LOVE the Fekkai Technician Shampoo and conditioner as you recommended. My hair is at it’s best!

Reply

Reika July 13, 2011 at 1:57 pm

I am so happy to hear that flyavsted! I am so glad you like the Fekkai Shampoo and conditioner. It is such an excellent brand, I have been a fan of Fekkai for so many years, their products really work!
Japan is a makeup shopping paradise. I can browse their shops from day to night, night to day :-)

Reply

Kiu July 12, 2011 at 2:02 pm

I definitely want to try Majolica Majorca! My eyes get watery on the outer corners as the day goes on and funny enough, dry eyeshadow works but all the liquid liners I’ve tried haven’t. Perhaps with MM I’ll find a liquid that actually stays put! Thankfully I’m studying abroad in Shanghai this fall semester since I prefer buying things in person if its the first time :)

Reply

Reika July 13, 2011 at 2:01 pm

Hi Kiu both the dolly wink and Majolica are very water resistant, hopefully one of them will work for you! That’s great to hear, Shanghai is a nice place, but I find the Japanese drugstore products in SH are more expensive than Japan, Hong Kong and Taiwan.

Reply

Katelyn July 12, 2011 at 3:35 pm

Great post! Where do you find these Asian brands in Sydney. And where can I get my hands on bioderma? I’m having a hard time finding it. Thank you!

Reply

Reika July 13, 2011 at 2:04 pm

Hi Katelyn, half of my Asian cosmetics were purchased online, half of them were purchased in Asia while I was there :-) Bioderma is such a great product! I couldn’t find it in Australia either so I bought it over ebay.

Reply

Amy July 12, 2011 at 4:11 pm

Such a nice and thorough review! thanks for sharing girl xxx

Reply

Reika July 13, 2011 at 2:04 pm

Thanks Amy :-)

Reply

onlyfr33b33 July 14, 2011 at 1:41 am

I’ve always had a good experience with K-Palette…until it starts to dry out, then it fades but leaves a tattoo-like mark!

Reply

Reika July 14, 2011 at 1:17 pm

My one is still going strong after 1 and a half months, so it’s not so bad for $10! :-) I have previously used a few high end ones which started to fade after 2 weeks, by the end of 1 month there wasn’t any ink left…

Reply

Eileen July 14, 2011 at 3:33 am

Very helpful comparison ;) !

Reply

Reika July 14, 2011 at 1:17 pm

Thanks Eileen :-)

Reply

Ling July 14, 2011 at 5:05 am

Awesome post! I have the Dolly Wink eyeliner too but I havent opened it yet…looks so good in its cute packaging lol

Reply

Reika July 14, 2011 at 1:19 pm

I know what you mean! I haven’t thrown the packaging out yet..it’s too cute to look at :-)

Reply

Jade July 18, 2011 at 10:05 am

Great comparison post, might pick up the dolly wink next time I’m looking for a new liner :)

Reply

TNA July 19, 2011 at 9:25 pm

I also love dolly wink eyeliner and bioderma.
thanks for your nice review :)

Reply

Iris July 20, 2011 at 2:08 am

helped me decide between dolly wink and k-palette.
I think I’ll try dolly wink (:
thank you!

Reply

anya October 12, 2011 at 12:21 pm

Did you try the K-Palette 24h Real Lasting Eyeliner in Jet Black/Black?

I’ve tried that one, the newer K-Palette 24h Real Lasting Eyeliner WP in Super Black one & the Dolly Wink one, and I found the newer K-Palette 24h Real Lasting Eyeliner WP in Super Black stays put the longest on my oily, watery asian eyelids. Give it a try ;)

Reply

MaryJane November 26, 2011 at 12:42 pm

I’ve been living in Japan for 3 years, and by looking at your blog I realized how I’ve been missing all the good products here!

Reply

Cheryl Chua January 2, 2012 at 1:36 pm

I believe what you may have tried with the K-Palette was the regular formula. You will know if it is the waterproof formula if there’s a WP printed on the pen. For some odd reason, the WP formula doesn’t leave a stain after it is washed. And it stays way longer too!

Reply

Adora BatBrat February 26, 2012 at 2:59 pm

Hi, I found your review so perfect I had to show it to my fellow goths in my own blog. On behalf of my readers and me – thank you for this one!
I hope it is okay with you:
http://adorabatbrat.blogspot.com/2012/02/make-up-review-liquid-eyeliner.html

Reply

forever23 April 14, 2012 at 1:07 pm

Are those liquid eye available in ManilaPH? Since im not very liquid eye “fan” thingy but still i wanted to try, I want the direct liquid eye pen (is that even the right term?) unlike the other brands that i used to see mostly in beauty shops, look like a nail polish container. Well, I hope I can buy one of those if there’s any chances, but i’ll try search for more. THANKS TO YOU! GODBLESS :)

Reply

UnitedInBeauty May 6, 2013 at 2:54 am

This is such a helpful post! Like you, I’m always searching for the better and blacker eyeliner. I loved the way you tested them for waterproofing and durability too!

Reply

Mia August 18, 2013 at 4:27 pm

BEST review ever!! Thanks for helping me choosing eyeliner! I’m going for Dolly Wink or Majolica! :)

Reply

Leave a Comment

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Previous post:

Next post: